1. Print this form and submit it by regular mail or fax, or
2. Download this file to your computer and open it with your word processor, then e-mail the completed form, or
3. Open this file in an HTML editor (such as Netscape Composer, which comes free with Netscape Communicator) and complete the form and then send it by e-mail, or
4. Download MS Word version of this form: Letter size and A4 size -- which can be completed and submitted by e-mail, regular mail or fax

Review DUE DATE: ________________   Referee Number or Name: ___________________________

Manuscript Number: ________________________________

Manuscript  Title: _____________________________________________________________________

Your Comments Below should be based upon the Type of Paper you indicated above.

Please rate and comment (in Parts B & C) this paper on:	Acceptable	Some Revision Required	Unacceptable
1. Importance of Issues Raised:
2. Adequacy of Literature Review:
3. Rigour of Methodology Employed:
4. Rigour of Analysis (appropriate interpretation):
5. Clarity of Writing, Explanations, and Concepts:
6. Suitability of Illustrations and Table (too many, too few, clarity):
7. Adequacy of Abstract (accurate summary of entire paper) and Keywords (up to 6):
8. Adequacy of Introduction (purpose and rationale):
9. Adequacy of Conclusions:
10. Accuracy of the Title:
11.Contribution to the Study of Tourism:

 
Do you recommend the paper for:

____  Acceptance as is
____  Acceptance subject to revisions
____  Rejection, but recommend major revisions and resubmission to the review process
____  Rejection

Part B - Evaluation Comments to be forwarded to the Author(s) - In particular, please address issues that you rated as Requiring Some Revision or Unacceptable, above. (these comments may be submitted on a separate sheet)